On an Independence Referendum
Posted by alangdundee on 8th May 2011
So the SNP have walked home in the Holyrood election with a majority. The whole election campaign Labour, Lib Dems and the Tories were talking about a vote for SNP being a vote for independence. The SNP barely mentioned it.
48 hours after the results are known the media has had saturation coverage of an independence referendum. This morning on the Sunday morning politics programmes Labour and Tory politicians were wheeled out and attacked the SNP because of all the talk of independence.
The tory went as far as to repeat the Wendy Alexander Bring it on
taunt to the SNP.
As daft as the phrase sounds, there is a minor point. In 2007 the SNP promised a referendum in 100days, er a year, er within the first term of office. The unionists allied in opposition enough to make the SNP bottle holding one. They are now hinting about one towards the end of the current term.
In addition the Tories supported holding the AV referendum even though advocated a No vote. If they see that the two positions are not contradictory then why do these parties not support having the referendum but then campaign against a Yes to independence result?
So on the one side you have the SNP trying to delay implementing the policy they exist for.
On the other you have the Lib Dems, Tories and Labour trying to block a referendum for a variety of public reasons (mainly cost) and private reasons (they don’t want it to pass). The arguments against didn’t stop Tories and Lib Dems supporting the recent AV referendum. Nor Labour the slightly less recent referendum on more powers for the Welsh Assembly.
As ever the goalposts have moved.
In the past few weeks Labour were saying a vote for SNP is a vote for independence
. Presumably now they would insist a referendum has to take place first?
Of course rags like the Daily Mail are a bit miffed. Apparently the rest of the UK needs to vote on Scotland being independent, it’s not just those in Scotland. To use the old argument, a husband and wife would both need to agree to a divorce or if only 1 wants it be forced to stay together?
Quite pathetic really.
Of course the logical end of this argument is ignored.
The first commenter on the article Muggins, Manchester I want out of the Union as well; the European Union. What’s the betting we don’t get a referendum on that one!
.
So does Muggins think that a UK referendum on leaving the EU would only be valid if the rest of the EU voted that the UK could leave?
Presumably not…
Posted in Campaign, Holyrood, International, Media, Scotland, SNP | No Comments »
